3Settimana·

This one or that one? 🤔

So far, I've been saving $JEGP (+0,17%) .

Right now, I’m thinking about adjusting my savings plan $WINC (-0,78%) .

What would you recommend, and why?

I’m already familiar with the expected comments that both options are uninteresting. 😉

I’d really like to hear your thoughts on @Raketentoni and its AI support.

20 Commenti

Raketentoni@Raketentoni

3Settimana

We’d be happy to take a look at that 🙂 To provide a meaningful assessment, we’d need a few details from you first:

- **Rest of your portfolio:** Which ETFs and individual stocks do you hold, approximately, and what are their weightings? Percentages are sufficient.
- **Strategy and investment horizon:** Are you primarily interested in ongoing income, long-term wealth accumulation, or a mix of both? When do you plan to use the money?
- **Distributions:** Do you already spend them, or are they reinvested? Is a specific distribution amount important to you?
- **Role in your portfolio:** Is this ETF meant to be the foundation of your portfolio or a smaller addition?
- **Risk tolerance:** What short-term losses could you handle, both financially and emotionally?
- **Reason for the switch:** What do you like better about WINC, or what do you feel is missing from JEGP?
- **Scope and taxes:** Do you just want to switch your future savings plan, or do you also want to sell existing shares? In which country are you subject to taxes?

This will help us determine which of the two is a better fit for your goal and your existing portfolio. The payout ratio alone wouldn’t be enough for me to base a decision on. 😉

•

Novius@Novius

3Settimana

Thanks for asking. For about two years now, I’ve been investing in a few dividend-focused ETFs with a fairly high monthly contribution rate, since I plan to take (early) retirement in about eight years. I’m currently reinvesting all the dividends until, in about 8 years, I’d like to stop reinvesting them and start spending them instead. I don’t want to deplete the accumulated capital itself; I’d like to have it available for my children later on. I’d like to adjust the savings plan; the funds I’ve saved so far will not be sold. Since I also own various individual stocks (some for over 20 years), I’m used to dealing with market fluctuations.

•

Raketentoni@Raketentoni

3Settimana

@Novius
Thanks for the clarification—that makes things a lot clearer. 🙂 So you want to continue building wealth for another eight years, then receive a steady income, and preserve as much capital as possible for your children. In principle, both ETFs could work for this. **However, based on the information you’ve provided, I don’t yet see a compelling reason to switch your savings plan entirely to WINC.**

For me, the key difference lies in the implementation:

With the $JEGP, JPMorgan relies on a deliberately defensive equity portfolio designed to be less sensitive to market movements. Additional income is generated by selling call options on stock indices.

$WINC systematically selects its stocks using mathematical models. Here, too, call options on stock indices are sold. In addition, the fund uses index futures to recoup some of the limited exposure to price increases resulting from the option sales.

In terms of ongoing costs, both funds are tied at 0.35% annually. There is also no longer any difference in the distribution frequency: both pay out monthly.

With JPMorgan, the more defensive equity portfolio takes center stage. With WINC, the additional futures are intended to recoup some of the market exposure lost through option sales. This makes WINC an interesting option, but it does not guarantee fundamentally better returns or greater security.

**The key point regarding your goal, however, is this: Not selling shares does not necessarily mean that your capital will be preserved.**

In addition to dividends, both funds distribute income from options strategies.
You receive these premiums in exchange for giving up a portion of potential price gains. They can cushion losses, but they do not prevent them. BlackRock explicitly mentions the risk that the derivatives strategy may reduce long-term capital growth and exacerbate capital losses. Conversely, this does not mean that WINC will inevitably distribute its net asset value. The total return remains the decisive factor.

Here’s a simplified example: If a portfolio starts with €100,000, generates a total of €6,000, and pays out €9,000, €97,000 remains. You haven’t sold any shares, but you’ve still consumed capital in economic terms. That’s why I would never automatically assume that a payout ratio represents a sustainable level of consumption over the long term.

For your children, inflation is another factor to consider:
Assuming 2% inflation, an unchanged €100,000 would have only about €67,300 in today’s purchasing power after 20 years.
**Do you want to preserve the current amount of money or its purchasing power?**
That determines how much growth is still needed in addition to the distributions.

For the next eight years, I would therefore focus primarily on the **total return after fees and personal taxes, assuming distributions are reinvested**.
A higher payout alone won’t benefit you during the accumulation phase if you’re reinvesting it in full anyway.
I also wouldn’t assume that the current dividend yield will still be available in exactly the same amount eight years from now.

My preliminary assessment would therefore be:

- **Continue contributing to JEGP** if you specifically chose this component for its more defensive stock selection.

- **Add to WINC** if you specifically want to take advantage of its different approach and diversify across two management strategies. That would be a reasonable decision; however, it does not result in additional broad diversification across asset classes.

- **Don’t switch your savings plan solely because of a higher distribution rate.** This will not result in a higher sustainable retirement income.

Both funds are also still relatively new:
JPMorgan launched in November 2023, and WINC in March 2024.
Their track record to date does not yet indicate a retirement solution that has been proven over decades.

To make a clearer decision, I’m currently missing, above all, details about your other ETFs—including their approximate weightings—the proportion of this income strategy within your total portfolio, and the monthly net amount it’s intended to generate later on.
With that information, we could assess whether WINC would be a sensible addition or mainly just duplicate something you already have in sufficient quantities.

Sources:

- [JPMorgan: JEPG Product Data](https://am.jpmorgan.com/de/en/asset-management/institutional/products/jpm-global-equity-premium-income-active-ucits-etf-usd-dist-ie0003uvyc20)
- [JPMorgan: Options Strategy and Its Limitations](https://am.jpmorgan.com/se/en/asset-management/adv/insights/portfolio-insights/pm-perspectives/equities/using-options-to-help-turn-market-volatility-into-extra-income/)
- [iShares: WINC – Strategy, Costs, Distributions, and Risks](https://www.ishares.com/de/privatanleger/de/produkte/335083)
- [BlackRock: Explanation of the Underlying WINC Strategy](https://www.blackrock.com/au/insights/ishares/case-for-income-in-ai-world)

•

Novius@Novius

3Settimana

@Raketentoni Thank you very much for your thorough explanations and your willingness to dive deep into the subject. I’m currently making monthly contributions to these ETFs:
$TDIV
$JEGP
$VHYL
$EUHD
$EXXW
$IEEM
$ZPRG
$FYEQ
$HIDR

I’m contributing to all of the above ETFs (except for gold) via the distribution option. I also have a few stock savings plans for selected individual stocks, but they’re negligible in this context. Overall, as explained earlier, the ETF savings plans are focused on building up a dividend cash flow that I plan to use starting in 2035. Until then, the payouts will be reinvested.

•

Raketentoni@Raketentoni

3Settimana

@Novius I'll be happy to get that ready for you this afternoon

•

Christoph@ChrisBizz

3Settimana

@Raketentoni Very interesting insights 👍🏻

•

Novius@Novius

3Settimana

@Raketentoni Thank you! By the way, my monthly savings for the ETFs mentioned above currently total about 1,500 EUR. And that number is on the rise…

•

Raketentoni@Raketentoni

3Settimana

@Novius
Thanks—that makes the portfolio clearer. 🙂 **I generally think WINC could be a good addition to your portfolio. However, based on the list, I don’t think that means you should completely replace your existing JEGP savings plan just yet.**

You already have several funds that focus on high-dividend companies: TDIV, VHYL, and ZPRG follow different selection criteria but are based on a similar underlying concept. With ZPRG, for example, additional criteria include at least ten years of consistent or rising dividends, as well as a positive return on equity and positive operating cash flow. These are different approaches, but they aren’t entirely separate investment worlds. :chatgpt-content-reference{index="0"}

EUHD and EXXW place additional regional emphasis: EUHD focuses on high-dividend, lower-volatility stocks from the Eurozone, while EXXW focuses on dividend-paying stocks from the Asia-Pacific region. This allows you to give greater weight to certain regions and selection criteria relative to your global funds. This may be intentional—but the actual impact depends on the amounts invested in them. :chatgpt-content-reference{index="1"}

**I would take a particularly close look at your emerging markets portfolio.** IEEM tracks the broad MSCI Emerging Markets index. FYEQ also invests in emerging markets but selects stocks based on quality and dividend criteria. Additionally, VHYL already includes emerging market stocks. This isn’t necessarily redundant, but it does mean that your total emerging market allocation is spread across multiple funds. :chatgpt-content-reference{index="2"}

An interesting detail: According to its fact sheet as of September 30, FYEQ had **47.9% in information technology**, with **34% in Taiwan and 21.6% in South Korea**. So a dividend fund doesn’t necessarily have to consist mainly of defensive consumer stocks and utilities. You already have a significant technology focus within this single fund. Without knowing the weightings, we don’t yet know how much of an impact it has on your overall portfolio. :chatgpt-content-reference{index="3"}

By the way, based on the linked ISIN, HIDR is the **HSBC MSCI Indonesia** fund, not a gold product. If you’re also investing in gold, this component is still missing from the list. I would view the Indonesia fund as a targeted country allocation: As of the end of August, it contained only nine equity positions and about **70.3% financial stocks**. That represents a significant concentration within the fund. :chatgpt-content-reference{index="4"}

What does this mean for **JEGP or WINC**?

JEGP already offers you a different income stream in addition to traditional dividends: option premiums, combined with a more defensive stock selection. WINC also uses option selling, but relies on a different systematic stock selection strategy and additional index futures for greater market exposure. A second provider splits the implementation between two management teams but does not create a new asset class. :chatgpt-content-reference{index="5"}

**My approach would therefore be: first determine the desired weighting of this options component, then decide whether JEGP should handle it alone or whether both should handle it together.** Splitting new savings contributions would make sense if you want to be aware of both approaches. I wouldn’t switch entirely to WINC just because of a temporarily higher distribution.

For your goal starting in 2035, I also wouldn’t base a fixed monthly expenditure on unchanging ETF distributions. I would plan for lower distributions and set aside a liquidity reserve for your planned expenses. The fact that you can withstand price fluctuations helps a lot; whether the income covers your expenses is a separate question.

At €1,500 per month, **€144,000 in new deposits** will accumulate over eight years—excluding returns and in addition to your existing assets. That’s why it’s worth allocating your savings contributions specifically according to your desired portfolio weights.

What I still need for a specific recommendation: **the monthly amounts per ETF, the approximate current portfolio weightings including your older individual stocks, your desired monthly net cash flow starting in 2035, and your country of taxation.** After all, small stock savings plans don’t automatically mean that your existing stock holdings are small as well. Percentages are sufficient for this.

Sources:

- [VanEck: TDIV Fact Sheet](https://www.vaneck.com/lu/en/library/fact-sheets/tdiv-fact-sheet.pdf), [Vanguard: VHYL](https://www.vanguard.co.uk/professional/product/etf/equity/9506/ftse-all-world-high-dividend-yield-ucits-etf-usd-distributing), [State Street: ZPRG](https://www.ssga.com/de/en_gb/institutional/etfs/state-street-spdr-sp-global-dividend-aristocrats-ucits-etf-dist-zprg-gy)
- [Invesco: EUHD](https://www.invesco.com/se/en/financial-products/etfs/invesco-euro-stoxx-high-dividend-low-volatility-ucits-etf-dist.html), [iShares: EXXW](https://www.ishares.com/de/privatanleger/de/produkte/251764), [iShares: IEEM](https://www.ishares.com/de/privatanleger/de/produkte/251857)
- [Fidelity: FYEQ Fact Sheet](https://www.fidelityinternational.com/FILPS/Documents/en/current/pro.en.xx.IE00BYSX4739.pdf)
- [HSBC: HIDR Fact Sheet](https://www.assetmanagement.hsbc.lu/api/v1/download/document/ie00b46g8275/lu/en/factsheet)
- [JPMorgan: Options Strategy](https://am.jpmorgan.com/se/en/asset-management/adv/insights/portfolio-insights/pm-perspectives/equities/using-options-to-help-turn-market-volatility-into-extra-income/), [iShares: WINC](https://www.ishares.com/de/privatanleger/de/produkte/335083)

•

Novius@Novius

3Settimana

Thank you again, dear @Raketentoni! The plan you’re looking at here is actually just a (smaller) part of my retirement planning strategy.

Based on the information you provided, I will not (!) invest in WINC but will stick with JEGP. Your assumptions regarding my reasons for choosing the individual ETFs were all accurate.

By the way, I’m no longer investing in the broad MSCI Emerging Markets index; instead, I followed your recommendation from a few months ago and switched to the EM Quality Income fund.

•

Schäfer2609@Schaefer09

3Settimana

I’ve also had the JEGP for 1.5 years (about 5% of my portfolio). As a complement to my other dividend-focused ETFs and individual stocks (core-satellite strategy),
I’m just letting it run as a personal experiment.
I currently have a savings plan set up for exactly the amount of the distributions.
Let’s see how this manually set up DRIP performs over the next 10 years.

••

Ichbinak63@Ichbinak63

3Settimana

I'm invested in both as well. As a 63-year-old baby boomer, I don't think the dividends (which boost my retirement income) are a bad thing. I'm aware of the pros and cons. I just reduced my JEGP position because I found WINC a bit more exciting.

•

NichtRelevant@NichtRelevant

3Settimana

A while back, I switched my position in $JEGP to $WINC, and I haven’t regretted it so far. While the distributions from JEGP were good, its price performance was rather lackluster or even negative over long periods. At some point, I lost patience.

I’ve held the majority of my WINC position for about a year now, and the price is up a solid 7%. On top of that, there are the distributions.
Of course, you can’t know what the future holds, but I feel much more confident with the $WINC.

•

Donkey Diktator@DonkeyInvestor

3Settimana

Neither of them is interesting 👍

•

Epi@Epi

3Settimana

@DonkeyInvestor That's what I thought about your wife and your side chick, too. 🤷

••

Donkey Diktator@DonkeyInvestor

3Settimana

@Epi You think our two women are uninteresting? No wonder yours is always coming over to me.

•

PiHu@PiHu

3Settimana

Hey, how are you doing in the JEGP right now?

••

Novius@Novius

3Settimana

@PiHu including dividends, currently around +5%

•

HardRockDividende@HardRockDividende

3Settimana

I have both. I’ve had the $JEGP since April 2025, and the $WINC for two weeks, shortly after hearing that it pays out monthly. Decide what YOU want. Research the ETFs, understand their opportunities and risks, and see if they meet your needs.

••

Max@Maximilian1

3Settimana

It was on "RTL aktuell" yesterday. Nothing new.

••

Lance@IsaiGM

3Settimana

winc will be better in a long term

••