(@TheBeginning) on getquin

1Yr·

I am thinking of moving my securities account from comdirect to Trade Republic. Comdirect is extremely expensive in comparison.

Who uses TR and can share experience reports? There is a lot of bad stuff on the net.

#comdirect

#traderepublic

45 Comments

Zoro@RoronoaZoro

1Yr

I use now for just under a year and am completely satisfied, you are indeed dependent on L&S as a broker, but otherwise I find's top design I find natural and easy to understand, fees are pretty low and the range of ETFs & shares is also now very good :) My deposits always arrive pretty quickly and since a few weeks can also collect directly from the bank, which was eigtl the only thing I had still missing :)

•

Smudo@Smudeo

1Yr

I'm happy with Comdirect, what's with the stinginess?

•

View all 8 further answers

Michael@MichaG83

1Yr

so I am with Scalable Capital - free broker, for savings plans, am quite satisfied. invitation link would also be on my profile :) I make individual purchases at smartbroker (from 500 free) what is important to you in the broker? individual purchases, savings plans, web or app?

•

View all 2 further answers

Chris@CashDividendGamer

1Yr

Overall, I am satisfied as a user. I find it positive that the offer and features have been further expanded over time (and hopefully still will be). If even more shares could be saved, they would basically be absolutely top for my needs (well, customer service would also be an issue, but I won't go into that now).

•

Janek@Janek93

1Yr

I am very satisfied with TR, especially the clear structure pleases me.

•

Jen@jen_mcduck

1Yr

I transferred my custody account from Comdirect to Scalable, mainly for ETF savings plans, the selection there is huge. Comdirect was too expensive overall. Trade Republic I use for individual stocks, lots of ETFs added there recently as well. I am happy with both.

•

Moritz@leveragegrinding

1Yr

There is a now functioning web version... Otherwise a stinknormalen broker for the cell phone. Only really negative point: If you are easy to influence TR seduces you to more frequent trading. But otherwise no real problems.

•

View all 17 further answers

Stockmarketbird@Stockmarketbird

1Yr

Just buy on TR or SC and then transfer to Comdirect, at least that's how I do it.

•

Show answer

Vince@coinvince

1Yr

I have been with TR for over a year and am very satisfied. I have never had problems with deposits / withdrawals or other. I am also with Scalable, but I find the optics terrible and I therefore no longer use. TR also regularly adds new themes/features. A few things are still missing, but that would be cosmetic.

•

Fritz@JCM

1Yr

I'm with Scalable and thinking about switching away. Is with then but somehow too unsafe to go to a neo-broker and park his entire fortune there. Even if it is an apples and oranges comparison, you have just seen with all the big crypto brokers how fast it can go. With TradeRepublik, I would always be afraid that I would no longer be able to access my assets or that shares could no longer be traded, etc.

•

View all 3 further answers

Join the conversation