5D·

Investing in times of a falling USD

What is it about?


As I wrote in my last post, the USDEUR exchange rate has broken its upward trend, which has been running since 2007, in the last few days.

attachment

Why is this a problem for investors?

A falling USD means capital outflows from the US market, which traditionally goes hand in hand with problems in the US and global economy and thus falling equity indices. In addition, a 30% depreciation of the USD means an additional 30% loss for investors in EUR. Ergo: Understanding the USD cycle is very important for your own investment strategy!


In the following article, I will 1. introduce you to the USD cycle, 2. explain which asset classes perform best in which phase of the cycle, 3. what to expect over the next few years from a cycle perspective and 4. how to profit from it.


The USD cycle


Here is the long-term chart of the USD index since the installation of the current international monetary system (Bretton Woods) in 1971:

attachment

A certain cyclicality of the USD is noticeable. It can be roughly summarized as follows:

High approx. 120 USD: 1971

Low approx. 80 USD: 1978-80 -30%

High approx. 160 USD: 1985 +100%

Low approx. 80 USD: 1990-95 -50%

High approx. 120 USD: 2000-02 +50%

Low approx. USD 70: 2007-11 -40%

High approx. 115: 2022-2025 +60%


If you look at the highs in 1969, 1985, 2001 and 2017, you can see a relatively stable 16-year cycle. The next high point would be around 2033. There is also a 16-year cycle for the low points: 1978, 1994, 2010. The next one would be around 2026. Roughly speaking, this results in the following cycle: USD falls for 9 years and then rises for 7 years. On average, the USD appreciates by 70% in an upward cycle and depreciates by 40% in a downward cycle (100 +70% -40% = 102). The economic reason for this cycle is probably to be found in the US election periods and the different economic policies.


Each cycle tells its own story:

1969-1978: Oil crisis and stagflation

1979-1984: Reaganomics

1985-1994: Political turnaround and emerging markets boom

1995-2000: Internet boom and emerging markets bust

2001-2010: Internet bust, financial crisis and emerging markets boom

2011-2016: Zero interest rate policy and US tech boom

2017-2026: AI boom/bust and Trump(?)


What does this mean for the next few years? The current phase did not look like a devaluation phase for a long time. We are still only 10% below the peak of the last appreciation phase 2011-16/17. The current depreciation phase ends in 2026/27. For the cycle of the last 60 years to be maintained, there would have to be a significant USD depreciation of 30-40% in the next 1-2 years.


Ergo: If the cycle remains intact, we are on the verge of a true USD crash! Of course, it will hit everyone unexpectedly, especially our political economists - but not you! You now know the cyclicality. How can you profit from it now?


2. the performance of asset classes in the cycle phases


Here you can see the real return (performance minus inflation) of the most important markets S&P500, emerging markets, gold and commodities in the individual phases of the cycle in USD (I have left out bonds):


S&P 500

Period Real (p.a.)

1969-1978 -0,5 %

1979-1984 4,4 %

1985-1994 10,9 %

1995-2000 17,5 %

2001-2010 0,0 %

2011-2016 10,3 %

2017- 2025 7,5%


MSCI Emerging Markets Index

Period Real (p.a.)

1969-1978 -

1979-1984 -

1985-1994 12,0 %

1995-2000 2,0 %

2001-2010 9,4 %

2011-2016 -3,4 %

2017- 2025 2,1%


Gold (USD per ounce)

Period Real (p.a.)

1969-1978 23,8 %

1979-1984 2,5 %

1985-1994 -4,9 %

1995-2000 -5,5 %

2001-2010 14,7 %

2011-2016 -5,0 %

2017- 2025 9,2%


Commodities (CRB/BBG Commodity Index)

Period Real (p.a.)

1969-1978 5,0 %

1979-1984 -2,1 %

1985-1994 -4,2 %

1995-2000 -0,4 %

2001-2010 5,0 %

2011-2016 -10,4 %

2017- 2025 -0.7%


If we select the top performer for each period, the following picture emerges:

Period 1st place (real return p.a.)

1969-1978 Gold +23.8 %

1979-1984 S&P 500 +4.4 %

1985-1994 EM +12.0 %

1995-2000 S&P 500 +17.5 %

2001-2010 gold +14.7

2011-2016 S&P 500 +10.3 %

(2017-2025 gold +9.2 %)


The result is quite clear: the S&P 500 performs best in the USD appreciation phases. Gold and, to a lesser extent, emerging markets perform best in depreciation phases. There is also an economic logic to this: when the US economy is booming, international capital flows into the US market, which strengthens the USD and causes prices to rise. Gold is traded in USD and becomes cheaper for ex-US investors when the USD falls and more attractive for US investors when share prices fall. Emerging market companies and governments are often indebted in USD, which lowers the debt burden when the USD falls.


3. cyclical forecast for 2026/27


a) The USD is likely to reach its cyclical low in 2026. As it is still close to the high of the last cycle, it should depreciate by approx. 30-40% over the next 1-2 years.


b) The S&P500 has gained an average of approx. 3.5%pa (real) during the devaluation phases. From a level of 2400 points in 2017, this would be approx. 4500 points at the end of 2026 with approx. 3% inflation, i.e. approx. 15% lower than today (5300 points).


c) Gold has gained an average of approx. 11.2%pa (real) during the devaluation phases. From a level of USD 1300 in 2017, 3% inflation at the end of 2026 results in a gold price of approx. USD 4900, i.e. around 50% higher than today (USD 3300).


d) For euro investors, the depreciation of the USD must also be taken into account. This means that an unhedged S&P500 ETF would be approx. 45-55% lower in 2026 than today according to the cycle and unhedged gold would be approx. 10-20% higher than today.


e) From 2027, the USD should bottom out and then rise again until 2032. This would then also be the performance phase for the S&P500.


4. strategies and investments


a) Passive B&H savings plan investors (S&P500/ MSCI World/ ACWI)


B&H investors remain consistently invested and continue to save in their ETFs. However, they should be prepared for a massive test of their strategy and nerves. The drawdown could be massive (approx. -50%) due to the falling USD and falling equity markets. Those who have added emerging markets should be less affected by a falling USD.


Those who have the opportunity can consider at least hedging the depreciation of the USD. A factor certificate or ETC is most suitable for this. If you reserve 10% of your portfolio volume for a factor 10 short USDEUR, you can at least cushion a good part of the USD depreciation.

  • Wisdomtree 5x Short USD EUR ETC, DE000A12Z322
  • Vontobel 10x Factor Warrant EUR long USD, DE000VP3NYZ9


An alternative would be to pause the savings plan for the equity ETF and instead invest in a currency-hedged gold ETC or simply a money market ETF.

  • WisdomTree Physical Gold - EUR Daily Hedged, JE00B8DFY052


Another option is to switch to currency-hedged ETFs or redirect the savings plan to them. Such ETFs are available cheaply for the S&P500, MSCI World and ACWI.

  • Invesco S&P 500 EUR Hedged UCITS ETF IE00BRKWGL70
  • iShares Core MSCI World UCITS ETF EUR Hedged (Dist), IE00BKBF6H24
  • SPDR MSCI All Country World UCITS ETF EUR Hedged (Acc) IE00BF1B7389


b) Active investors (market timing, trading, stock picking)


Friends of sophisticated, strategic market timing have a few more options.

They can either switch immediately into a currency-hedged gold ETC or wait for a correction and invest in gold near the SMA100 via a factor ETC, for example.

  • WisdomTree Physical Gold - EUR Daily Hedged, JE00B8DFY052
  • WisdomTree Gold 2x Daily Leveraged JE00B2NFTL95


Or you can bet directly on a falling USD with a low-cost factor ETC/certificate (see above)


In addition to gold mines, equity fans can also target emerging market companies with high USD debt, as these benefit particularly from a falling USD. This can quickly add up to several 100% gains.


Finally, connoisseurs can bet on falling prices on the US markets with inverse index ETFs. However, due to the asymmetrical volatility, a good strategy and disciplined implementation are a must here.

  • Amundi MSCI USA Daily (-1x) Inverse UCITS ETF Acc LU1327051279


What other ideas do you have for profiting from a USD devaluation?


5. summary


The USD cycle has been very reliable over the last 60 years. Knowing it helps to better understand the major movements in the financial markets. The current break in the USD trend could be followed by a rapid and sharp depreciation of the USD in the next 1-2 years with serious consequences for the financial markets, especially for German investors with USD investments. Those who know the cycle can protect themselves against it or even profit from it.


I have hereby warned you.

And now on with the business!


Your Epi

93
32 Comentários

imagem de perfil
Thanks for the article. What you can add to 4a is that a classic B&H investor gets more shares for his euros during a weak dollar. This may not matter in the short term, but it boosts returns later on.
8
imagem de perfil
@MineraLogik If the portfolio is 35% under water, it doesn't matter how many shares I get for what.
Above all: Who assures me that my assets in the portfolio will become a booster(!) and were not boosters(!)?

It is primarily about hedging the portfolio with regard to currency fluctuations
1
imagem de perfil
@MineraLogik You are of course right that the EUR buys more when the USD and equity markets are weak. However, you are assuming that both will then rise again. And then the EUR will buy less again.
There are just these huge fluctuations - you can take advantage of them or sit them out. In the long term, they balance each other out.

Note: The cycle becomes particularly relevant at the start of the payout phase. This is when the yield succession risk can increase massively, so that your safe withdrawal rate is only 2-3%. In the end, you'll need a EUR 1 million portfolio to even come close to closing the pension gap.
1
imagem de perfil
2
imagem de perfil
1
imagem de perfil
Very important topic. Thank you very much for this!

That's probably it for the dollar milkshake theory 😏

The currency allocation of my entire portfolio is currently 26% USD.
As a result, I will not be shifting extra positions into EUR hedged variants.

Do you still have Bitcoin in your portfolio? I think I saw it as a position recently.
2
imagem de perfil
@BigMo Why don't you write something about the Dollar Milkshake Theory and why that was it? Some people might be interested. Definitely me!

I no longer have BTC. For 3xGTAA it would first have to be above SMA150, but it could be interesting for my punter share as soon as the current downtrend is broken. 👍
1
imagem de perfil
USDJPY / the yen in general is again much more meaningful for risk assets. 👍 But yes, forex drives equities
1
imagem de perfil
Great contribution!

As a BH, however, I lack the courage and knowledge to change my strategy :)
1
imagem de perfil
@MWS As you can see, the USD index remains fairly constant over the various cycles. If you just hold on for a very long time, you don't have to change anything in your strategy. 😬
1
imagem de perfil
@Epi thank you, I plan to live long and healthy :D
1
imagem de perfil
I'm always careful with cycles like that. Looking in the rear-view mirror is nice, but whether it is representative of the future... Possible.
But it's just as possible that Trump 2 represents a structural break. 🤔
I mean the guy is doing a MAIA speed run. (Make America Isolated Again)

The administration that comes after him is not to be envied.
That is, assuming there is an administration after him. 😅
1
imagem de perfil
@TotallyLost Basically, I agree with you. Cycle analyses should always be treated with caution. A cycle often breaks as soon as it is discovered and published.
But 60 years is a real house number. Especially as the USD cycle can certainly be explained in economic terms.
As long as the currency system allows capital to flow freely, even Trump will be able to do little to change the cycle.
It is quite astonishing that just now, when a strong depreciation of the USD should be taking place in terms of the cycle, Trump is appearing on the scene and making exactly the right policy!
Everything fits here: USD trend break, cycle, Trump. 😲
2
imagem de perfil
Great contribution, thank you!
1
imagem de perfil
Great contribution, thanks for that! 👍
1
imagem de perfil
So this gold ETC, I find it interesting
1
imagem de perfil
@GoDividend Me too, because gold rises especially when the USD falls.
Unfortunately, I can't say anything about taxation. Maybe you can find out something?
imagem de perfil
@Epi No delivery claim found to date on which the tax-free sale after one year is based
1
imagem de perfil
@Epi if we continue the thread: what do you think is the combination of euro hedge plus possible capital gains (including taxation on sale) greater than a euro-denominated (but not hedged) investment in gold etf/etc with tax-free gains? That will be the Gretchen question
imagem de perfil
@GoDividend Surely it's easy to do the math. Two investors start: one with unhedged, tax-free gold, the other with hedged, taxable gold.
If the USD depreciates and gold stays the same, then 2 has an advantage because 1 simply makes a loss. If USD depreciates 20% and gold appreciates 20% in USD, then 1 has +-0 and 2 has +15% after tax. If USD depreciates 20% and gold appreciates 40%, 1 has +20% tax-free and 2 has +30% after tax.
So far, the hedged gold ETC has always had an advantage. Only if the USD does not depreciate or appreciate and gold appreciates will 2 be at a disadvantage compared to 1.

This is actually also logical.
2
1
It would be interesting to deep dive on which industries and/or companies have the biggest inblanace in terms of debt in USD and revenue ex-USD which could benefit from a falling dollar
imagem de perfil
Exciting contribution! Is there some kind of rule of thumb for the proportion of dollars in the portfolio and from what proportion one should think about hedging?
I am currently at around 40%.
imagem de perfil
imagem de perfil
I am confused about the Hedged versus UnHedge ETC like you mentioned. So I asked AI:

Scenario : Trump Crashing the USD (USD depreciation/devaluation)

Your Expectation: You believe Donald Trump's policies will lead to a significant depreciation of the US dollar (EUR/USD exchange rate goes up significantly).

- Unhedged Gold ETC: If you held an unhedged gold ETC priced in USD, a crashing dollar (meaning the euro is getting much stronger) would make the USD-denominated gold much cheaper in euro terms. This strong positive currency movement would significantly enhance your returns (or significantly offset losses) from the underlying gold price.

- Hedged Gold ETC (EUR-Hedged): The hedging mechanism would neutralize this substantial positive impact from the weakening dollar. The ETC's returns would largely reflect the gold price in euros, without capturing the significant gain from the favorable currency exchange.


Therefore, if you strongly expect the US dollar to crash (depreciate significantly), an *unhedged ETC* is likely to be more rewarding. You would benefit from both the potential safe-haven demand for gold (potentially increasing its USD price) and the significant positive impact of the weaker dollar when converting those USD gains back into euros.

So it does says the Contrary.
imagem de perfil
@GenoGenova AIs are not always the smartest. Ask yours to check its answer. Here is the answer to your question from Deepseek:


In the event of a USD crash, a **EUR-hedged gold ETC** would behave differently compared to an **unhedged gold ETC**, depending on the exchange rate movements between USD and EUR. Here is a detailed analysis:

### 1. **Unhedged Gold ETC (USD-based)**
- The price of gold is usually quoted in USD.
- In the event of a USD crash (sharp depreciation of the dollar), the price of gold in USD tends to rise, as gold acts as a safe haven currency.
- **But:** As the ETC is priced in EUR, a USD weakness leads to a **negative currency effect** for European investors.
- If the USD falls against the EUR, the gain from the rise in gold is partially or fully offset by the currency loss.
- **Performance:**
- Gold price in USD **rises** (positive).
- USD/EUR exchange rate **declines** (negative for EUR investors).
- Net effect depends on how much the USD falls and how much gold rises.

### 2. **EUR-hedged gold ETC**
- Here the currency risk (USD/EUR) is hedged.
- The ETC only tracks the pure gold price performance, without exchange rate effects.
- In the event of a USD crash:
- The gold price in USD rises (as with the unhedged ETC).
- However, the hedge compensates for the currency loss, so that the performance **depends only on the change in the gold price**.
- **Performance:**
- Gold price in USD **rises** (positive).
- Currency effect is neutralized (no loss due to USD depreciation).
- The ETC benefits **fully** from the rise in gold, without exchange rate losses.

### **Summary: Performance comparison in the event of a USD crash**
| Scenario | Unhedged Gold ETC (EUR) | EUR-hedged Gold ETC |
|-------------------------|---------------------------|------------------------|
| **Gold ↑ in USD** | Positive | Positive |
| **USD ↓ vs. EUR** | Negative (reduces profit) | Neutral (hedged) |
| **Overall performance** | Lower (as currency loss) | Higher (pure gold performance) |

### **Conclusion:**
- A **EUR-hedged gold ETC** would perform **better** in the event of a USD crash because it avoids the currency loss.
- An **unhedged gold ETC** could perform worse despite rising gold prices in USD if the USD falls sharply against the EUR.

For investors who want a pure gold price exposure without currency risk, the **hedged ETC is the better choice**. On the other hand, those who deliberately speculate on USD strength might prefer the unhedged ETC.
As someone who will soon have to invest a high six-figure amount over a 15-year horizon, I am considering whether European ETFs would also be a good alternative to mixing with emerging markets, or an all-world ETF, which, given the cycle you describe, will rebalance with an admixture of some EM and EU small cap.

Edit: My current plan is a portfolio of equities via ETFs 36% US, 36% EU, 12% Asia, 3% Pacific +Rest
Bonds: +8% EU, 2.5% Canada
(what is missing from 100% are small caps through the ETFs)
imagem de perfil
@AristideHalbseid Sounds like a plan. I can't say whether it's a good one.
In any case, you would have a high cluster risk in equities. Have you ever considered the Epi portfolio: 60% world ETF, 20% gold, 20% BTC?
That would give you much more asset class diversification. Otherwise, perhaps strategy diversification via these assets would be a good idea: 50% B&H, 50% SMA200.
1
@Epi Thanks for the food for thought.
1
How does the financial sector usually hold up in phases of USD devaluation?
imagem de perfil
@AristideHalbseid Perfect question for an AI bot! 👍
Participar na conversa