1Wk·

Yield comparison Allianz vs. BTC

I have just entered a few scenarios in ChatGpT and have compared a long-term investment in $ALV (-0.23%) with an investment in $BTC (+0.59%) compared. I find it amazing that a defensive stock like the $ALV (-0.23%) does not have a much worse return than a very risky investment in $BTC (+0.59%) .


Here is the prompt:

Compare an investment in Allianz shares with a current price of €364 and a dividend yield of 4.2% with an investment in Bitcoin at a current purchase price of €100,000. Calculate the annual return (CAGR) over a period of 20 years, assuming that the Allianz share price rises by an average of 3% per year and the dividend is increased by 7% each year. The dividend is to be reinvested annually. In this scenario, the price of Bitcoin is € 1,000,000 in 20 years.


Answer (shortened):

Under these assumptions, the annual return (CAGR) for Allianz would be approx. 10.2% and for Bitcoin approx. 12.2% - Bitcoin would therefore have the long-term return advantage, while Allianz would have the steady cash flow.

1
10 Comments

profile image
You didn't compare Allianz with Bitcoin, but two fantasy values 👍
21
profile image
You can also compare apples and pears
3
Oh boy. Bitcoin is tax-free after one year. And not dependent on any quarterly figures or management.
2
I understand how you could come up with a value for Allianz, even if it will be difficult over 20 years, but price targets for Bitcoin have no basis whatsoever, or am I missing something?
1
profile image
What kind of question is Bitcoin, of course?
1
profile image
Have you also included the taxes for dividends and at the end on the realization of price gains? The return on the Allianz share suffers as a result.
1
profile image
Hey there, buddy! Your life is crying out for more $BTC! No go, nobody is born with a USB stick full of blockchain magic, you'll learn that. :)
profile image
Ragebait
Join the conversation