2Yr·

Now that the Gerd Kommer ETF has collected the 100 million $GERD (+0.61%) and the $K0MR (+0.53%) Finanzfluss also took a closer look at the ETF and uploaded a video today

Was taugt der neue Welt-ETF von Gerd Kommer? - YouTube

www.youtube.comWas taugt der neue Welt-ETF von Gerd Kommer?

23 Comments

TomTurboInvest@TomTurboInvest

2Yr

The approach of determining the weighting according to market capitalization and GDP, combined with its factors, is interesting, but I do not see any long-term outperformance compared to a "normal" World ETF, if only because it allows a maximum weighting of 1% per company. It is precisely these large companies that have contributed to the good performance, or have grown so strongly that their weighting has become correspondingly large. If you reduce them, you cut the performance...

•

Moritz@leveragegrinding

2Yr

@TomTurboInvest not necessarily, like everything else it's speculation. Just because the giant companies have been growing faster in recent years doesn't mean it has to stay that way.

•

TomTurboInvest@TomTurboInvest

2Yr

@leveragegrinding yes, it may well be, you only know afterwards 😉

••

Felix@Investor_in_Jogginghose

2Yr

This guy has harmed German investors and now he is taking the money out of their pockets.

•

Stulle 🥪@Stullen-Portfolio

2Yr

@MiIliardenmehling
So far, the opinion has been that Kommer has contributed to the establishment of ETFs in Germany... You seem to disagree - can you tell us why?

•

Marco@HodlReiniger

2Yr

@MiIliardenmehling Is there a legitimate reason for this?

•

Stulle 🥪@Stullen-Portfolio

2Yr

So, what's it good for? 👍/👎

••

Marco@HodlReiniger

2Yr

@Stullen-Portfolio The bottom line is that Red Flag is a solid all-in-one solution alongside ftse and co, just a little higher in terms of ter, but this may also decrease over time

•

Stulle 🥪@Stullen-Portfolio

2Yr

@DividendenReiniger
Thanks for the summary...the conclusions immediately after the launch (at least those of the more "authoritative" reporters) were similar.

••

Stulle 🥪@Stullen-Portfolio

2Yr

@DividendenReiniger
You used to be invested there too, didn't you? What prompted you to switch?

••

Marco@HodlReiniger

2Yr

@Stullen-Portfolio Position was so small that it had no added value or sense, but will be available for election later as Acc when I have reached the tax-free amount

•

Stulle 🥪@Stullen-Portfolio

2Yr

@DividendenReiniger
Ah, okay. Thank you.

••

IchPutzHierNur@IchPutzHierNur

2Yr

puke with the guys

••

Marco@HodlReiniger

2Yr

@IchPutzHierNur Strong justification.

•

IchPutzHierNur@IchPutzHierNur

2Yr

@DividendenReiniger if you have a clue, you can see it in the videos, you don't need to "justify" anything at all

••

Marco@HodlReiniger

2Yr

@IchPutzHierNur Why did I expect a "normal" explanation :D

•

IchPutzHierNur@IchPutzHierNur

2Yr

@DividendenReiniger You're not serious, are you? Finanzfluss spreads misinformation on certain financial topics. Forex, pension products, P2P loans and much more. His site is also programmed solely to make money via affiliates, which works, and not to recommend honest products that don't make any money. Just watch the relevant videos and if you know anything about finance, which I assume you do, then you'll see what I mean.

••

Deleted User

2Yr

Comment was deleted

KingC@RaphGM

2Yr

@PremiumSparkassler Exactly what I thought, TER is one of the most important parameters for me.

••

KevinE@KevinE

2Yr

@RaphGM depends on what is important to you. As far as I know, Kommer focuses on uncorrelated assets, so his drawdown should be lower than with a standard ETF. But of course we will have to wait and see whether this works.

•

Stulle 🥪@Stullen-Portfolio

2Yr

@PremiumSparkassler
"Ultra-diversification" is probably a difference to such normally diversified ETFs as ACWI etc., plus multi-factor, plus GDP, plus max share...🤷 Whether these are then ultimately actual advantages, nobody really knows...

•

yieldhunter@randomdude

2Yr

@Stullen-Portfolio True, time will tell ... But 100 million in such a short space of time is pretty amazing. If that comes mainly from private investors, it shows how well known he is and how big his fan base is.

•

Stulle 🥪@Stullen-Portfolio

2Yr

@randomdude
Joah, the conclusion could fit 👍

••