10Mon·

Future Financing Act - The first sensible traffic light law to (significantly) improve capital-forming benefits?


With regard to the traffic light government and the Future Financing Act, one could probably aptly say: Even a blind, deaf and leg-amputated chicken sometimes finds a grain of corn.


I would like to focus on one (very positive) point of the bill in particular: Namely, the Amendment to the Fifth Capital Formation Act


Sounds boring? It usually is. The law forms the basis for capital-forming benefits.


Previously, you could invest 40 euros per month in capital-forming benefits. Up to the income limit of 17,900 euros per year, you were then also entitled to the so-called employee savings allowance.

If you invested in a securities savings plan, you could receive another 80 euros from the state (I'm leaving out other investment options such as a building society savings contract, as these are not to be changed by the law).


Calculation example (income under 17,900 euros):

  • 40 Euro VL per month
  • Investment in a fund or ETF (assumed return 7%)
  • After 7 years employee savings allowance of 80 Euro per year
  • Saved value: ~4,311 Euro plus 560 Euro employee savings allowance results in ~4,871 euros
  • This would correspond to a return of ~10,4%


Calculation example (income over 17,900 euros):

  • 40 Euro VL per month
  • Investment in a fund or ETF (assumed return 7%)
  • After 7 years employee savings allowance of 80 Euro per month
  • Saved value: ~4,311 euros


What changes should the law bring?

  • The income limit of 17,900 euros is to be completely eliminated - everyone is therefore entitled to the employee savings allowance.
  • In addition, the limit of 400 euros will be increased to 1,200 euros per year.
  • This will also significantly increase the maximum employee savings allowance. Namely from 80 euros to 240 euros per year
  • Important: The regulations are to apply only to investment savings, not to building society savings contracts, bank savings plans,... - The aim is to promote share ownership


Calculation example from 2024:

  • 100 euros VL per month
  • Investment in a fund or ETF (assumed return 7%)
  • After 7 years, employee savings allowance of 240 euros per year
  • Saved value: ~10,779 Euro plus 1,680 Euro employee savings allowance results in ~12,459 Euro
  • This would correspond to a return of ~11%


So if you continue to receive 40 euros from your employer, you would have to add 60 euros out of your own pocket. After 7 years, this would correspond to a personal investment of 5,040 euros.

In relation to the "own contribution", this would correspond to a return of over 25% p.a. correspond!


Of course, the law still has to be passed (probably in the 4th quarter of 2023) and there may well be changes.

Nevertheless, in my eyes this would be an extremely good start to promote the share culture by law.


A tax-free investment portfolio for retirement provision (as in many other countries) would also be much better for me, but I think this is a better or easier way to bring a large part of the population along.


What do you think of this proposal? And how have you been using your capital-forming benefits so far?


In my case, the VL are invested in an MSCI World. Unfortunately, I don't receive any subsidies, so I would be extremely happy if I could achieve a significantly higher return from 2024 onwards.


Source: https://www.bundesfinanzministerium.de/Content/DE/Gesetzestexte/Gesetze_Gesetzesvorhaben/Abteilungen/Abteilung_VII/20_Legislaturperiode/2023-04-12-ZuFinG/1-Referentenentwurf.pdf?__blob=publicationFile&v=2


#etfs
#aktien
#altersvorsorge
#vl
#vermögen


44
22 Comments

profile image
Sounds good, but I think the impact will not be very big. Problem: 50% don't know what stocks or ETFs are, just as little what the difference between investing or speculating is😅.
8
View all 2 further answers
profile image
My AG treats me to a whole 6.65 VL per month 🙃
6
View all 4 further answers
profile image
That would be a start. However, the amounts are ridiculously small in view of the pension problem ahead. It would be time for a major initiative, such as a tax-free pension deposit.
4
View all 2 further answers
profile image
Such posts are really worth something, thank you for that, you have earned my subscription! 🍹 oh and that here too:@ccf
2
profile image
Interesting law. Thanks for sharing. I can't quite understand your calculation though. If I understood it correctly, you assume that the e.g. 40 euros VL from the AG are available without consideration. However, this amount is subject to tax and social security contributions, which again leads to deductions on the payroll. Are these taxes not relevant for the consideration of the personal return?
2
Show answer
profile image
With me there are 27 € per month from the AG the migrate into an Oskar depot (Roboadvisor). (Before I had invested my VL through my insurance man but only after 3 years realized how much return that costs me. Keyword issue surcharge. I will sell the shares from the old VL depot as soon as the price has recovered. They will then go into my main portfolio.
2
profile image
1
profile image
It would be interesting to know how the subsidy for existing VL contracts is calculated. From the effective date of the law. Only with new VL contract. Or even retroactively, which I do not think.
1
View all 2 further answers
profile image
Thanks for the informative post 😃✌🏻
1
profile image
@ccf Very informative and important article. Top.
1

Join the conversation