2Yr·

Which broker do you actually use? Rather a traditional one like ING DiBa, Consorsbank or Comdirect or rather one of the neobrokers á la Scalable Capital, Trade Republic or Smartbroker and co?

I am with Scalable and very satisfied so far ☺️ But I am thinking about whether I should go to a second broker for ad hoc trades and only save my ETF through Scalable. #broker

28 Comments

Adrian@buysedip

2Yr

As well as. At ING, we save in etfs, and at TR we save in equities.

•

devnerd_daddy@devnerd_daddy

2Yr

@buysedip Exactly so :) The selection at ING is just nice and since savings plans are free, you can save virtually everything. Only single transactions for 4.90 € + brokerage are bissel steep. 3€ without brokerage I can put up with, then I would be out with TradeRepublic.

•

Adrian@buysedip

2Yr

@devnerd_daddy that's right. I just like to have etfs and stocks separate.

••

View one more answer

Bohn3_@BOHN3_

2Yr

I have mine with TR and Scalable. My girlfriend hers at DKB and for our child we will go to ING I think^^

•

Roc2103@Roc2103

2Yr

Comdirect 👍

••

Stephan@Blumentopf

2Yr

Trade Republic and the Zero Broker from Finanzen.net. Also for Commerzbank employee shares. As a children's securities account DKB and ING.

••

Give Me Your Money@GiveMeYourMoney

2Yr

I am with Comdirect because there were good junior deposit offers

••

Robenito83@MoneyRulesTheWorld

2Yr

I buy ETFs at ING, individual stocks at TR and crypto at BSDEX

••

Kay 🍀.@EurieNet

2Yr

Flatex and Degiro.

••

M W@wenmar77

2Yr

scalable Capital and ebase

••

Michael@TheAstronaut

2Yr

Comdirect - because you can buy everything there, the ETFs run as savings plans, TR for dividend portfolio. Children have a junior account at Comdirect, where monthly ETF is saved... PS: it is also important to me to have a full-fledged fall-back solution (Comdirect), if the Neobroker times zickt.

••

Finanzgraf@Finanzgraf

2Yr

I use TR

••

Finanzgraf@Finanzgraf

2Yr

Crypto with Bison

••

Kevin E.@KevinE

2Yr

I have the Genobroker from Spardabank. It's far too expensive, but as I've been holding shares there for 30 years - and the cost values haven't been entered even after years - I'm sticking with it for now. I've also set up a custody account with ING for a few savings plans.

••

InvestmentFeldwebel@InvestmentFeldwebel

2Yr

DKB for large investments and for savings plans Comdirect

••

Andreas@Andreas1991

2Yr

Now

••

Schweizer_Investor@Alumdria

2Yr

Swissquote with me in Switzerland. The transaction fees are quite high, but the account fee of CHF 60 a year is fine. And the selection of shares is huge.

••

Marsch@Marsch

2Yr

Flatex

••

Flo@blue75

2Yr

TradeRepublic👍

••

Bali Pardeshi@Bali93

2Yr

Interactive Brokers, Smartbroker and Deutsche Bank

••

Joshy@Joshy

2Yr

I tested all the usual neobrokers and Comdirect. I got stuck with Trading 212 and Trade Republic.

••

Noah@NoLimits

2Yr

Swissquote Swiss online bank

••

Markus@MHInvest

2Yr

I am with flatex for long-term investments and Trade republic for trades and derivatives trading

••

Stefan@Hoernchenfreund

2Yr

Evening. I currently use three neobrokers and a custody account at the Sparkasse (legacy). Scalable for ETFs Traderepublic for shares. But I've also been with Finanznet Zero for a few days now. I'm the one-off payment type and there you save the order fee from €500. Makes a difference for some trades. And yes, Scalable also has premium funds that can be traded free of charge from €250. But not Vanguard😅. I am currently in the process of reducing Sparkasse, as ETfs are often hidden behind the "well-sounding" names and a TER of 1.93, for example, is too high for me 🤔😉.

••

Souli@Souli1984

2Yr

Scalable and basically satisfied. But I would like a more accurate account statement. I really miss that, especially for the smaller amounts.

••

triathlonfan@triathlonfan

2Yr

Comdirect for the current account and as a custody account for special share/fund purchases, Scalabe for ETF savings plans and Trade Republic for individual shares

••

SoToRe@SoToRe

2Yr

I used to use DKB for ETF savings rates for many years. But I only keep them as they are now.

Now with Scalable Capital active with a premium savings plan. The ETF savings plans are now running alongside the shares.

Bison for a few cryptos.

Deutsche Bank only passive, as the employee shares have to go there. But not really actively used.

To summarize:
Scalable Capital + Bison

••

Michael@MichaG83

2Yr

ETF and share savings plans with Scalable, individual purchases with Smartbroker (from €500)

••