Jamie-Lee (@investmentmaus) on getquin

8Mon·

Which one makes more sense from your point of view?

I know that the way I've just planned it doesn't make much sense... hence the question! You are a great help and I implemented your tips for my portfolio yesterday, but I can't get any further :(

$$SPPW (+0.25%) and $LCUW (+0.19%)

please be kind, I am sensitive 😂

24 Comments

Kevin E.@KevinE

8Mon

It's best to link both, then you can compare them properly. First enter a dollar sign and then select the product $IWDA (e.g.).

•

View all 3 further answers

PowerWordChill@PowerWordChill

8Mon

It doesn't matter, the $SPPW has a slightly better tracking difference
https://extraetf.com/de/etf-comparison?products=IE00BFY0GT14-etf,LU1781541179-etf
However, the main point against $LCUW is that Amundi are French... 😂

•

Show answer

Carlo@Carlooooo

8Mon

I would prefer the one from Spdr, as the fund domicile is Ireland and you therefore pay less withholding tax on US dividends, which is good for performance

•

Show answer

Uwe@SchlaubiSchlumpf

8Mon

First of all, it's cool that you're implementing the ideas so quickly! As some have already said here, they are very similar. As some have already written, I would go for the one from Ireland. But it also depends on whether you like synthetic replicas or not. (Do a quick google if it's unclear, it's never bothered me before). Wouldn't use both as they track the same index.

If you want to keep and build up some of the individual stocks you have, go ahead. Pick a few and really get to grips with them. You already have the positions anyway. With little knowledge, an ETF like the one you have chosen probably has a good risk/reward ratio.

•

Jamie-Lee R.@investmentmaus

8Mon

And the next question: do I get vacation and Christmas bonuses - is there any reason not to put them into the etf in August and November as a "total" and individual investment?

•

View all 2 further answers

Luffy@Luffy3D2Y

8Mon

I would take the simple $SPPW. The other one is based on the MSCI World Index, but with a small modification.

•

Iwas M.@SSIT

8Mon

iShares calls it "Core", but it's actually just a normal MSCI World. So it should be the same ETF twice from different providers, and I would go for just one to keep the whole thing leaner. :)

Is the second one accumulating/acc or distributing/distributing? There may still be a difference.

••

View all 3 further answers

Krush82@Krush82

8Mon

It makes no significant difference whether you choose the first or second ETF for your asset accumulation. The first is accumulating, the second could be distributing. Unfortunately, there are no details on exactly which product is involved.

••

McCrispy@McCrispy

8Mon

What about this one $ISAC

••

Deleted User

8Mon

Comment was deleted

View all 4 further answers