Heiko · 2022-10-28T08:32:16.819280Z

TradeRepublic now finally with #etfs from #vanguard , #vaneck and #invesco. And a #sparplan can now be executed like other #brokern also be executed from 1€ and also weekly. Class optimizations, improvements. Now still the allowance for the spouse can deposit. 👍 How do you see the changes? What are you missing #traderepublic still missing?

2Yr

Actually pretty awesome, that would have been the only reason I would have wanted to switch to Scalable so far :D

•

16

•

Adrian@buysedip

2Yr

@RoronoaZoro scalable has never suited me just from the user interface. Tr is really nice and clean...

•

4

•

Zoro@RoronoaZoro

2Yr

@buysedip Exactly, that's why the Vanguard ETFs would have been the only reason for it, but I never did it, it's not that important to me :D

•

3

•

Heiko@ReichDurchSparen

2Yr

@buysedip I also find it really not so good and manageable at Scalable. Sure, when you get used to it. But good is different...

••

Heiko@ReichDurchSparen

2Yr

@RoronoaZoro yes, you mean Vanguard? For me, one thing that makes TradeRepublic much more "attractive".

••

Zoro@RoronoaZoro

2Yr

@ReichDurchSparen Yes, oops, I forgot to write that above :D

•

1

•

Heiko@ReichDurchSparen

2Yr

@RoronoaZoro I read it then afterwards only, also sorry :-)

••

six@six

2Yr

@RoronoaZoro have only this year transferred everything from TR and ING to Scalable Capital. So now everything back to TR 😂 Anyway, they have the better interface and at least the return display in %. Well but Scalable has just the Prime Broker. That's not bad either.

•

2

•

Heiko@ReichDurchSparen

2Yr

@six scalable is also available in the free version. Hihi, you move more often with your depots than with your household. 👍☺️

•

1

•

six@six

2Yr

@ReichDurchSparen Well, I don't think I'll get there for a long time yet 😂

•

1

•

Macho Man@MachoMan

2Yr

What is new with TR is that the savings plan execution can be set weekly.

•

4

•

Stewie G.@Stewie

2Yr

@AndreasD I find one of the best innovations

•

2

•

Heiko@ReichDurchSparen

2Yr

@AndreasD hi, Ando, thank you. But it's also already in the description 😉👍

••

Staatsmann@Staatsmann

2Yr

A working link to getquin is missing, so I'm sticking with Scalable 😇

•

3

•

Heiko@ReichDurchSparen

2Yr

@Staatsmann yes, I'm still missing it too. But I don't want to share my TR depot here anyway. ☺️

••

Viktor Wagner@MrxVito

2Yr

@Staatsmann the connection is possible after all?.. or what does not work? :)

•

1

•

Staatsmann@Staatsmann

2Yr

@MrxVito Feels like it's the connection with the most issues with FinAPI 😅 As much as TR doesn't go wrong with Scalable.

•

1

•

Heiko@ReichDurchSparen

2Yr

@MrxVito It hasn't even worked for me yet. It always fails with "Open Banking" because of the PIN that was supposedly sent to my banking app. So TR. There comes nothing. And the support of TR wrote me then that a connection to getquin is NOT possible...😂😂😂

••

Johannes@Johannes_J

2Yr

@Staatsmann But there are nice programs. with which you can download all PDFs from TR at the same time, so it is then also well possible

•

1

•

Heiko@ReichDurchSparen

2Yr

@Johannes_J and the automatic sync goes then also?? 🤔

••

Johannes@Johannes_J

2Yr

@ReichDurchSparen It's just a program for the PC that downloads all your documents, which you can then upload to getquin. I don't use the API anymore, because it only causes problems (with all brokers).

•

1

•

Paul@renditefarm

2Yr

The interface only records estimated times and prices here. I'd rather have clean PDFs, that annoys the hell out of me with Scalable.

•

1

•

Heiko@ReichDurchSparen

2Yr

@Johannes_J oh so ok. I'm still quite new here, so far it has worked quite well with scalable. Except that the times of transactions were not supplied. :-/

••

Heiko@ReichDurchSparen

2Yr

@renditefarm yes thank you. I just read your comment. Exactly my point of criticism too.

••

View all 5 further answers

Ella Marie Waschbär@DividendenWaschbaer

2Yr

Then I really think about closing SC. That is of course mega

•

3

•

Heiko@ReichDurchSparen

2Yr

@DividendenWaschbaer I also. Leave Scalable only because there runs my 100% cashback depot and I want to have that separately. It works for that. And I can deposit it here easy. 😂👍👍

•

1

•

Ella Marie Waschbär@DividendenWaschbaer

2Yr

@ReichDurchSparen For me, after the closure of SC Trade Republic would be my only broker. The SBroker is in the process of closing. They are good but just too expensive 🤷🏻‍♂️ I'm still not sure if I prefer to keep two brokers. Kost ja nüscht 😅🤷🏻‍♂️

•

1

•

Heiko@ReichDurchSparen

2Yr

@DividendenWaschbaer No, exactly. You can already separate something. Or you also start to collect cashback or so to invest this then. Then a separate deposit is good :-)

••

Oli@Dividendenolli

2Yr

@DividendenWaschbaer Trade Republic has become the better with taxes properly pay or you get there still so problems as last year?

•

1

•

Heiko@ReichDurchSparen

2Yr

@Dividendenolli what problems have there been? I haven't had any yet. Only the double taxation of $BNTX (BioNTech) annoys me colossally... let's see when that will be corrected.

••

BLAUGE@BLAUGE

2Yr

Just stopped my savings plans at SC and ING. Everything comes to TR👌 I've been a customer of TR since the beginning and it's nice to see that something is still happening with them and innovations are introduced.

•

2

•

Oli@Dividendenolli

2Yr

@ReichDurchSparen I had problems with the tax office because too little taxes have been paid by the broker

•

1

•

Heiko@ReichDurchSparen

2Yr

@BLAUGE I think so too. So little by little, many desired features come.

••

Heiko@ReichDurchSparen

2Yr

@Dividendenolli oh gross. Ok, for 2021 I haven't done the taxes yet. Let's see...

••

Ella Marie Waschbär@DividendenWaschbaer

2Yr

@Dividendenolli So far I have not had any problems. In fact, 2021 is the first year where I had to pay taxes at trade republic. But that is only a few cents withholding tax. Never recalculated the tax. Also this year I am still under the exemption order. But I will keep an eye on it. Thanks for the tip.

••

Divmann@Divmann

2Yr

Are the savings plans <€10 then also without third-party fee?

•

2

•

Heiko@ReichDurchSparen

2Yr

@Divmann hmm, I haven't set one up yet. Was in the brief mention nothing of.

••

Oli@Dividendenolli

2Yr

@Divmann according to current price list still from 10€

••

Tony@TBStyler

2Yr

@Divmann hä, savings plans have never had third-party flat rates

•

1

•

Divmann@Divmann

2Yr

@TBStyler And my question is whether this also applies to <€10

••

Tony@TBStyler

2Yr

@Divmann yes, according to the documents to my just created savings plan already

•

1

•

Tony@TBStyler

2Yr

@Divmann no fees for buy, sell 1€

•

1

•

Niklas@Rathi

2Yr

Deposits by direct debit should also finally be possible 🔥

•

2

•

Heiko@ReichDurchSparen

2Yr

@Rathi Really? Even for normal savings plans? So automated? I've always thought that Scalable was great.

••

Zoro@RoronoaZoro

2Yr

@ReichDurchSparen But is not yet unlocked, "coming in the next few weeks" is said by TR ;)

•

2

•

Heiko@ReichDurchSparen

2Yr

@RoronoaZoro Perfect, thanks for the addition.

••

How$y 🗽@Howsy

2Yr

I still need the $SPYD and then they would have me completely...

•

1

•

Adrian@buysedip

2Yr

@Howsy they have now after all

•

2

•

How$y 🗽@Howsy

2Yr

@buysedip you are right 😮

•

1

•

Heiko@ReichDurchSparen

2Yr

@Howsy then they have you now completely 🙌👍

••

six@six

2Yr

@Howsy Haha just also checked. now is just really the question whether there a move also so problem-free works. regarding date and course of the purchases. has someone experience? ok. What I'm still missing at TR is Euwax Gold 2, but I'm thinking about selling in January (after 1 year holding period) and put it into shares.

•

1

•

ad_absurdum@ad_absurdum

2Yr

So SC was my Favoriet, because savings plans from 1 € and more execution times. If TR now also has this is n change really interesting. Especially since I can save at SC neither $MDLZ nor $LOW as a savings plan.

•

1

•

Heiko@ReichDurchSparen

2Yr

@ad_absurdum great, that it would also bring you something. Then go ahead and do it. 👍

••

ad_absurdum@ad_absurdum

2Yr

@ReichDurchSparen What still prevents me is that fragments would have to be sold.

•

1

•

Heiko@ReichDurchSparen

2Yr

@ad_absurdum when transferring the securities account, you mean? Yes, that's stupid. Then transfer and leave SC open with the fractions. Depending on how many and how high the value is.

•

1

•

Stewie G.@Stewie

2Yr

I finds mega

•

1

•

Heiko@ReichDurchSparen

2Yr

@Stewie I still megaer... 🚀🚀

•

1

•

Zackdela79@Zackdela79

2Yr

Horny changes! But allowance spouse would really be the crowning glory 👑

•

1

•

Heiko@ReichDurchSparen

2Yr

@Zackdela79 Absolutely. Then write to them about it. The more who complain, the more likely it is that something will happen. 👍

••

Zackdela79@Zackdela79

2Yr

@ReichDurchSparen I have already - unfortunately not even get an answer :-(

•

1

•

Heiko@ReichDurchSparen

2Yr

@Zackdela79 One came for me. But only after the motto "let's have a look"...

••

NoBrainer@NoBrainer

2Yr

Notice of termination with Scalable is out 😂

•

1

•

Show answer

Jos-hua27@JoshuaKu

2Yr

Couldn't they have done this a bit earlier? I just moved my portfolio to Scalable

•

1

•

View all 3 further answers

Pjotr@SparrowPiet

2Yr

Definitely nice.
However, I'm still missing the ETFs from State Street Global Advisors - SPDR products!

After all, they are one of the TOP5 ETF providers.

Greetings

•

1

•

View all 3 further answers

Hamburger@Hamburger86

2Yr

Finally, I would say! After moving all my ETFs to Scalable, I'll probably be moving again soon 🤣

With TR, the document management is the only thing that doesn't work well, everything else is mega...

•

1

•

Show answer

Paul@renditefarm

2Yr

Does anyone have experience of the Scalable to TR custody account move? Will the price history of ETF savings plans be transferred reliably?

•

1

•

View all 4 further answers