1Yr·

Bitcoin Shitcoin Depot


Hello everyone,


A quick question for everyone: I would now like to continue my $BTC (+0.15%) -savings plan again, but I would like to move away from Bitpanda due to the opaque costs + spread.


What is your favorite broker for Bitcoin?

It would be important for me that the costs + spread are transparent and that savings plans can be created.

In the following comparison, 21bitcoin would probably be my favorite, but only possible via app: https://www.finanzfluss.de/vergleich/bitcoin/sparplan/


Thanks already!

attachment
10
70 Comments

profile image
Bison.
You have a spread, but no transaction fees. I personally find it easiest for tracking here on Getquin.
What I buy, I also have 1:1 on my wallet after the transfer.
10
profile image
@Alpalaka and you could also buy $EWG2 right there 😂
1
profile image
@six With 12 savings plan versions, that's an incredible difference of €5.
I'd be poor if I took Bison :D
profile image
@six I would block you immediately for the tip
1
profile image
@Testo-Investor:D

What are your backgrounds?

You have Binance, right?
profile image
@Alpalaka Have a look at my page, I wrote a very long report about stock exchanges and BaFin licensing, that it is only a sham security, although it is simply a complete monitoring nothing more.

That is the main reason and depending on the costs the main reason why I trade on Binance no BAFIN and the cheapest fees on the market and on top of that super secure because one to one insurance on $500 billion!!!!
profile image
@Testo-Investor Spread is higher. But somehow I have more confidence in the Stuttgart Stock Exchange than in any other crypto exchange.
But I also don't have a savings plan, but rather buy in tranches.
I would continue to buy there, as I don't have any doubts that if I buy 1 BTC and then transfer it, it will only be 0.9999.
3
profile image
@six Don't take it personally, but unfortunately you have no idea. For the following reasons the trading volume on Binance is 20-40 billion dollars a day in Bitcoin alone. Binance manages $500 billion in crypto assets... Binance has one-to-one insurance on every dollar invested in crypto.

So you're telling me you trust a booger exchange in Stuttgart more than the global market leader where all the billionaires have millions of billions of euros ????

Do you figure it out yourself or do you really think the millionaires would leave their money there if we were in any way unsafe? Thank you, topic closed 💪💪💪

And precisely because you buy spot in larger industries, it must be super interesting for you to have low fees or am I seeing it wrong zero, 1% to 1.5% that's worlds ... and especially if you buy spot, you can immediately send the coins to your wallet if you don't have any trust, which I find totally stupid ...

As I said, it's useful personally, but you'd better find out more and I can post again about how Binance secures its crypto holdings and what security mechanisms have now been implemented.

And just because the exchange is in Germany, I wouldn't trust that . The basic principle of crypto is freedom and you make yourself completely naked, so every transaction is monitored by you and if your face doesn't suit them at some point then that's it with you - that's the next reason why I don't trade on German exchanges because I'm exactly fed up with the whole system that is currently running here.

As I said, please don't take it personally, but such statements unfortunately make me a bit angry.
1
profile image
@Testo-Investor No problem, don't take it personally. And I was already at Binance. But then I went to Bison. I just feel more comfortable there.

A quick google:

Is Binance a reputable provider?

Although Binance is not regulated by the German financial supervisory authority BaFin, the exchange is still considered a reputable provider. This is supported by the large number of users and the high trading volume. Nevertheless, due to the existing restrictions and the uncertain future, it is not advisable to use it.

Source:
https://www.handelsblatt.com/vergleich/binance/#:~:text=Obwohl%20Binance%20nicht%20durch%20die,Zukunft%20von%20der%20Nutzung%20abzuraten.
profile image
21Bitcoin is great. For a savings plan, however, I would now recommend Strike - after the first week, savings plans are completely free of fees :D
1
profile image
@stefan_21 As long as the costs are 0.xx%, I'm happy :D
How can you imagine that BTC are automatically sent to the wallet when a certain amount is reached? Does this work smoothly or do you do it manually?
profile image
@Alpalaka Doesn't Strike have a spread?
profile image
@Alpalaka yes exactly, I've been using 21Bitcoin for a relatively long time and still have my monthly savings plan running there...
You can set up an auto wallet transfer for e.g. 0.01 Bitcoin and as soon as the value is reached, your Bitcoin is sent directly to the stored address. 21Bitcoin even subsidizes the transaction fees and you always have to pay a maximum of 1000sats fees - regardless of how much the transactions in the Bitcoin network currently cost.
1
profile image
@stefan_21 that sounds very good.
Thank you!
1
profile image
@Cyonix Strike has recently transformed the spread model into a transparent fee model:
https://strike.me/blog/from-spreads-to-fees-simple-transparent-and-cheap-pricing-for-bitcoiners/

Now that they have removed the fee on savings plans, one can certainly wonder if there will be a bit of spread on it again. I haven't found any official information on this yet.
profile image
@stefan_21 But you can't receive btc yet. Is that correct?
profile image
@Alpalaka Yes, that is correct. They are currently working with the authorities. But it should be possible to deposit and sell Bitcoin within the next few weeks/months.
But it hasn't been a problem for me so far :)
With Strike, on the other hand, this would already be possible now
profile image
@stefan_21 I just read through the roadmap yes.

You hodl all the way to the graveyard? :D
1
profile image
@Alpalaka definitely the majority :)
But I'm also prepared to take a few profits in a possible bull run. I will sell a maximum of 30% and then probably shift it into an ETF... but I will probably never have less than 70% Bitcoin in my portfolio again
1
profile image
@stefan_21 speak in concrete numbers.... If Btc costs e.g. 60k$ .... I make 500€ per week for example and say from 500€ directly to my wallett.... What are the fees?
View all 7 further answers
profile image
I very often use Youhodler as an on/off ramp. You don't have a savings plan option there, but I just had a look because the fees are directly in the trade (BTC 50 Euro Buy = 0.15 Euro Cent fee) They just want people to trade "leverage" on the platform, but you don't have to and I would strictly not recommend it. Buy and Hodl is the motto.
PS: Of course the fees are higher if you use a KK, I have always parked some money there via SEPA!
1
profile image
Reading your post makes me realize that I really need to look into this as well. At the moment I'm still buying from Trade Republic. The reason was laziness, which is now costing me money...
profile image
@Ash The Bitpanda savings plan was really easy. The savings plan ran every Tuesday at 8 a.m. for a year.
But the 1.5% spread/fees are actually too much for me
1
profile image
@Alpalaka You can write and mention me at @Ash when you have decided on a new broker. I'll follow this with interest :-)
profile image
@Ash I'll do it.
I'll have a look at 21bitcoin at lunchtime
1
profile image
@Ash Have a look at my page ... I have published several posts and guides on Binance here and why it is the best exchange
1
profile image
@Testo-Investor I'll take a look. Thank you 😊
1
profile image
@Ash I have now signed up and registered
Take a photo of the front and back of your ID, take a selfie, say three numbers out loud and bingo.
It all looks very clear and simple at first glance
2
profile image
@Alpalaka All right, I'll have a look after reading the posts from @Testo-Investor this evening.
2
profile image
@Alpalaka solid, if you have any questions, please contact me at .... I always dip € in usdc because the spread is better than if you were to buy in euros .... Trade -> convert -> € in usdc done
profile image
@Ash I set up a standing order on my "normal" account, which transfers 50€ to 21bitcoin every week for testing purposes.
21bitcoin immediately converted the 50€ into Bitcoin/Sats, but 0.49€ in fees were incurred, which corresponds to approx. 0.98% fees. I will write to customer service about this.

The exchange was triggered on 16.08.2024 at 03:04h, 1BTC = 52.779,13€
1
profile image
@Alpalaka Wow, thanks for your feedback and the insights. Unfortunately, I haven't gotten around to looking into it in depth yet. I look forward to any further feedback from you on this topic. 👍🏼❤️
View all 13 further answers
profile image
I use Coinfinity. I also have a discount code for the trading fees ;)
profile image
@Peter69 What are the fees?
profile image
Via the ledger and then bitcoindirect, I transfer 60€ via savings plan and bitcoins worth ~58€ arrive.
profile image
@Age65 phew, those are comparatively high fees
profile image
@Age65 too expensive
profile image
profile image
@PunktPunktKommaStrich 0.3% too expensive
profile image
Binance, I think you should have understood that by now from my post 😂 Auto invest is called a savings plan there. You can go down to 1 hour and even determine the time with daily or whatever .... 0.1% fees if you trade with bnb even only 0.075% fees. Largest and most liquid exchange. One-to-one insurance on all assets, so your coins are 100% insured at the rear.
profile image
@Testo-Investor That's actually true :D

But why are there fees of 1.75% in the link above?
Can you understand them?
profile image
@Alpalaka No, you have fees of 0.1% with Binance .... Yes I can understand that and I also check that because I use Coin Tracker and so every transaction is automatically matched with Binance and it matches 100% with the zero, 1% fees
1
profile image
Mexc has the lowest fees and spreads I know. Order fees 0% and maker/taker fees are between 0.1% & 0.01% for spot purchases. After that, I would send the purchased cryptos to a cold wallet such as Ledger or Bitbox.
profile image
@Benni-KryptoandStocks great thanks!
I already have a cold wallet lying around anyway
1
profile image
Bitpanda has at least an EU license - should also play a role in the selection in my opinion
profile image
@TheBrock Well, it actually goes to my wallet relatively quickly anyway. So that's of secondary importance :)
1
profile image
Find the spread completely normal compared to other brokers
profile image
profile image
I've been with Relai for years. Simple, transparent. Do only that.
If you want to try it out, with REL168083 you save 0.5 % fees.
profile image
Join the conversation