2Yr·

❗️Nachlassplanung and provision for a situation in which you can no longer make your own decisions könnte❗️


❗️Einleitung


As I found out in my question a few days ago, there is a lot of interest in this topic here. As I was able to find some time in between at Easter, here it is.

In my opinion, younger people in particular are often not well prepared, or not prepared at all, for situations such as sudden death or an event that renders them unable to make important decisions about their own lives. Of course, these are events that are often far away. Moreover, the thought of one's own death is not particularly pleasant. Nevertheless, I think it is important to deal with it so that your own wishes are respected as best as possible. This often doesn't take much time.

I would like to point out in advance that, based on my knowledge, I generally assume that this is correct and want to keep it as simple as possible. However, there is no guarantee of completeness here. I would also like to point out that I am not a legal advisor, so everyone is responsible for themselves.


❗️Vorsorge for a situation in which you can no longer decide for yourself


Imagine the following situation: Person X has a serious car accident. He survives seriously injured and is now placed in an induced coma. As X is unable to make decisions about his affairs due to his (temporary) incapacity, someone else has to do this. But who?

Many people assume that this is automatically done by the wife or parents. This is wrong. If X has not made any arrangements, a court-appointed guardian must be appointed. Although this can also be done by a relative, it takes some time, may cost money and means a lot of paperwork with the court for the relative. In addition, the caregiver may have to account for all the expenses they have incurred on behalf of the person being cared for and provide invoices.

To prevent this, X could determine in advance who can represent him in such cases and how his wishes are to be taken into account. There are several ways to do this: Care directive, living will or health care proxy. As the health care proxy is the complete package, so to speak, it will be discussed in more detail.


❗️ Healthcare proxy:

This allows you to determine who makes decisions on your behalf. All areas of responsibility can be specified separately, for example health matters or residence. If the authorized representative is to carry out real estate transactions, it is advisable to issue a notarial power of attorney. In other cases, it is perfectly sufficient to download the template from the BMJV and fill it out (see here: https://www.bmj.de/SharedDocs/Downloads/DE/Service/Formulare/Vorsorgevollmacht.html). Filling this out takes less than 5 minutes, but saves relatives a lot of time. It would also be possible to register this power of attorney in the register of powers of attorney (vorsorgeregister.de) for a small fee so that the power of attorney can be found if the worst comes to the worst.

It is also important to mention that the power of attorney should be granted to someone you trust. As the authorized representative can carry out many actions without control, this provides scope for fraud and embezzlement.


❗️Nachlassplanung

It should be said in advance that it is important to always review and, if necessary, amend your own estate planning in the event of changing life circumstances.

In my opinion, estate planning is important so that one's own will is respected in the best possible way and thus disputes in the family environment can be avoided.


1 Who decides what I inherit?

If no instructions have been made, the inheritance is governed by the provisions of Sections 1922 et seq. BGB. In the case of a testator with a child and wife (statutory matrimonial property regime), for example, this results in a share of ½ of the estate for each.

However, it is possible to make your own arrangements. This can be done, for example, in an individual will, a spouse's will or an inheritance contract.


2 How do I write a will?

It is important to comply with the formal requirements (§ 2247 BGB). So: handwritten (not!! printed out), date, place, signature with first name and surname. In addition, testamentary capacity (= legal capacity) must be present at the time. A will can also be drawn up with a notary, who will then deposit the will with the local court. If it is a joint will between spouses, it is sufficient for one of them to write the will and the other to co-sign it. This can also be drawn up by a notary. The price of a notarized will depends on the amount of assets, but can quickly run into four figures.


3 What does it say?

The heirs are named in the will. As precisely as possible with surname, first name, date of birth and possibly also the place of residence. Quotas can be allocated (not a must, in case of doubt it applies that the appointment has been made in equal shares). Withdrawals of compulsory portions are generally not possible. In addition, an executor could be appointed to ensure that the instructions are enforced.


4 And then?

Once the will has been drawn up, it should be kept in a safe place. Of course, it makes no sense to hide the will under the carpet. It should be stored in a place where it can be found by the heirs. If a will is found, they are obliged to send it to the probate court. It will then be "opened" at the relevant probate court and if the heirs require a certificate of inheritance (for example, to gain access to a deposit), the heirs must apply for a certificate of inheritance.


That's all it really is. As I want to keep it simple and don't want to give a lecture on inheritance law (I certainly couldn't, as a few years have passed since my studies), I'll leave it at that.

In some family constellations, it would certainly be too complicated for a layperson to draw up a will by hand, so in these cases I would always refer them to a notary. They will provide guidance and legal advice during the notarization process.

If there are any questions, I will be happy to try to answer them.

I have done my part. Now it's your turn (who haven't made any arrangements yet). Hopefully I have been able to encourage some of you to take care of these things.

69
60 Comments

profile image
@ccf

Unfortunately, I've been putting off this topic for far too long.
12
profile image
@six then get to the topic if you have time 👍🏼
profile image
@tim1 yes in any case. My sister-in-law's boyfriend suddenly had several strokes in his brain in his mid-30s. They both have a young daughter. There were no patients available. That was a really difficult matter, and it's been a while now. Wanted to do it afterwards actually also necessarily.
profile image
Very interesting, thanks for the great post @ccf
7
profile image
Some things are well regulated in Switzerland, others are not. If I were to die, I would have a large part already settled. What worries me again and is a huge issue is the digital estate. What happens to my wallets (lost?), my photos (almost a film of life) and files (cloud). Plus social media et al. I haven't sorted that out yet. I'm leaning towards bank box with passwords and "instruction manual". What do you think?
2
profile image
@Andimoneych Either let the heir(s) in on everything beforehand. Or as you said. Depends on the situation, of course. Provided you trust those, for example children etc, a combination of both is likely to be appropriate.
profile image
@tim1 Makes perfect sense. When you get to a certain age, you definitely cut back or carry over certain things. Hopefully in the next 50 years I'll still be alive, I'm just assuming if something sudden happens. Of course, a locked letter in the apartment is also a good solution. But can also be manipulated more easily in the worst case.
1
profile image
@Andimoneych perhaps include it in the will. As a rule, this should be sealed.
profile image
@Andimoneych at least with Apple, to help a family member recover access to iCloud (including photos) after a loved one's passing, they can follow these steps: https://support.apple.com/en-us/102431
Hope it helps!
profile image
Is it possible to sell one's own inheritance during one's lifetime?
1
profile image
@EnjoyCapitalism Since there is no expectant right or claim before death, this is not possible. After death, you can assign (sell) your share of the inheritance. Before death, a waiver of inheritance in favor of another person would be conceivable, who would then offer money for it accordingly.
1
profile image
@EnjoyCapitalism hope I have understood the question correctly.
profile image
@tim1 so if I contractually stipulate that someone pays me a sum X and is entitled to my full inheritance in return, provided there is no compulsory heir, would that be legally binding?
profile image
@EnjoyCapitalism that would be an inheritance contract. The contract creates a bond and the person would then be your heir. This is also conceivable if there are beneficiaries entitled to a compulsory portion. They would have to claim their compulsory portion against the heir.
1
profile image
@tim1 ok thanks for the info
1
profile image
@ccf and THANK YOU! ❤️
1
profile image
@ccf People and now not only read and liken but also act! For you and your loved ones!
1
profile image
1
profile image
1
profile image
Cool contribution. A topic what I have times so not noticed the last few years. Maybe it's time 🤔
1
profile image
@CryptoClothingForEveryone you should definitely think about it.
profile image
1
profile image
Very good article! Perhaps it would be useful to add a living will and account/deposit powers of attorney etc. to the whole story? Then it would have been covered in one article for many people.
1
profile image
@TradingmitIdee Thank you. Living will would have fitted in, but many people know it and it is not mandatory. I have left it out for the sake of clarity. And there is no need for a bank power of attorney if you have a notarized health care proxy or general power of attorney.
1
profile image
1
profile image
Important topic and thanks for the clarification! @ccf
1
profile image
Thank you for this contribution!
1
profile image
1
profile image
My husband and I have had our signatures on the health care proxies (the simple form from the BMJ) notarized by the care authority (€10 per notarization), as our local land registry accepts this. 😍
1
profile image
@FrauAnna Unfortunately, there are still some older judicial officers who are apparently of the opinion that this is not sufficient for 29 I GBO 🥴 Although this is clearly regulated in the wording of the BtBG. In this respect, it is now a good and cost-effective alternative to a notary.
profile image
Thank you very much, I had a different idea about the health care proxy. 👌🏻
1
profile image
@DenisSt I'm glad that it has helped you. How did you imagine it?
profile image
@tim1 I assumed that my wife automatically has the corresponding powers. I think that's also logical for a non-lawyer.
1
profile image
@DenisSt Yes, that's true. Unfortunately, there are many things that laypeople see as fair, but which are ultimately different.
profile image
@tim1 you have certainly helped me, thank you!
1
profile image
A very important topic that is forgotten far too often. Thank you for this important contribution!
1
profile image
I think it's a bit bad that people who don't think about it are dependent on the legal guardian in every respect. And if the partner, mother or similar disagree on medical issues, I don't even know if the legal guardian's decision can be challenged?
I understand the basic idea, but the implementation is a disaster.
profile image
@leveragegrinding If relatives are available and suitable, they are generally appointed as guardians first (as they are volunteers). However, if a professional guardian is appointed, they must, like everyone else, take the wishes and needs into account as far as possible. If this is constantly disregarded, dismissal may be considered. Otherwise, the guardian is authorized to make decisions within the scope of their duties. In principle, nothing can be contested retrospectively due to legal certainty. Certain actions, such as withdrawals from savings accounts, etc., must always be approved by the guardianship court.
profile image
At what age do you recommend it? 🙈 I'm actually refusing to think about it right now, but since something can always happen suddenly, it's actually an issue that should be addressed early enough, right?
profile image
@Jenmadness I think that applies to all ages. You have wishes about how you should be treated when you are no longer able to communicate them? Then you need it. If you don't care then you don't need it, but it will help your relatives so you need it
3
profile image
@Jenmadness A health care proxy is always required as soon as you have legal capacity.
A will is not absolutely necessary. It just depends on the constellation. If you are single (at least not married) and have no children, your parents would inherit in equal shares. It wouldn't necessarily be necessary to make a will and name your parents as your heirs.
However, if you have a friend to whom you are not married and you want him to inherit from you, you would have to name him as your heir in your will.
1
profile image
@GoDividend Yes, I've actually already had this case due to an operation mistake, but I was actually glad that I was still able to decide for myself whether I would agree to an emergency operation or would die in four months, since this incident I've actually been a bit reluctant because I don't really trust anyone in this regard.

Edit: but it's probably not the same thing, it's probably about if I wouldn't have woken up from the coma, right?
profile image
@Jenmadness If you can act yourself, there is no need to appoint a representative. But there are also urgent situations where you cannot act yourself but it would take too long for a guardian to be appointed. Not necessarily from a medical point of view. There may also be financial matters that need to be dealt with.
1
profile image
@Jenmadness That's my opinion. If you cannot express yourself (are not legally competent) then what you have specified takes over. For example, you want x operations out of the comma yes no
2
profile image
@GoDividend @tim1 so that would definitely make sense... 🥲 Mehh... so if I don't want to be operated on again if such a case should recur, I have to put that in writing.
profile image
@Jenmadness If you don't trust anyone completely, you could limit the areas of responsibility or give precise instructions that should apply unequivocally.
1
profile image
@tim1 Is there any way to get help if you want to write something like this?
profile image
@Jenmadness Notary (somewhat more expensive) or care authority. They can also notarize it for a small fee. They are actually available in every major city.
2
profile image
The compulsory portion can be withdrawn, but unfortunately the hurdles are very high. But it can be overridden somewhat by an executor. I'm currently working on this as a child of divorce 🤯
profile image
@Spoony1986 I'm aware of that, that's why it says "in principle" 😅 The requirements in 2333 BGB are very high, you're right.
Surely you mean an executor, right? An executor only comes into consideration if the heirs are unknown and there is a need for security.
1
profile image
@tim1 yep, correct. Was too early for my little mind 🙈
1
profile image
So me and my wife have a disability insurance that is also paid out in the event of death or all at once when we retire. We also have long-term care insurance that pays for a carer ... And the option that she kills me as soon as I get dementia, Alzheimer's or the like, which unfortunately she will never do, but is one reason why I support euthanasia.
View all 2 further answers
profile image
Thank you, I hope it's just as easy in Austria!
Show answer
Deleted User
2Yr
Comment was deleted
View all 3 further answers
Join the conversation