21H·

Hello dear community

I would like your help, especially those who have a custody account with Smartbroker or Scalable. I'm thinking of moving my securities account from Consors because the costs are really exorbitant. The only reason I still have it is because I have a few share savings plans there that are not tradable at TR and there are none at Flatex. I would therefore be very grateful if someone who is there could check for me whether they can be traded there as a savings plan and whether I can also transfer fractions. A sale and new purchase in a new custody account is out of the question due to the high costs. Specifically, it is about

$CDE (+0,46 %)

$IPX (+3 %)

$MP (+1,97 %)

$PPTA (-1,12 %)

$DEFI (-0,9 %)


Many thanks for your help. If you have any other suggestions for depots with other providers where this is possible at a reasonable price, I would also be interested in them.

1
16 Commentaires

With Scalable you can set up savings plans for everyone.
And according to the AI support, fractional transfers are possible
2
image de profil
@Nova78 https://www.finanztip.de/wertpapierdepot/depotwechsel/ all but one user say that fragments cannot be transferred...
image de profil
@Nova78 Thank you for the information
@Multibagger Funny, I asked the internal AI support 3 times and they told me that it is not possible... the first time he said it was possible. Sorry 🙈
image de profil
@Nova78 That is not the crucial point. I find it much more strange that you say that a savings plan is possible with the stocks and another @schlimmschlimm here has written that it is not possible with Scalable with any of the stocks.
@Multibagger so I can click on the savings plan button and can also enter an amount for your
positions... so it should work after all. I did the same with my ETF there, so I know how it works...
image de profil
I would recommend Finance Zero. In my opinion, it's the best neo broker or on its way to becoming one. I only see two disadvantages at the moment: when you sell a position, there are often two transactions, one for the whole shares and a second transaction for the fractions and since there is an order fee for transactions under 500,- €, it can happen that you pay a fee of one euro twice to liquidate a position. To be honest, this has happened to me very often. The second disadvantage is that all savings plans must have the same payment method. You cannot save this and that ETF by direct debit and save another position from the clearing account
2
image de profil
@Iwamoto Thank you
1
image de profil
Fractions are not transferred anywhere, but are sold automatically when the entire portfolio is transferred and deleted.
All securities are available from Finanzen.net Zero in the savings plan.
1
image de profil
@AlterMann Thank you very much for your quick reply. And what else is finanzen.net Zero like? And are there any fees for the savings plans?
image de profil
@AlterMann the reviews on Google are rather poor. Depot transfer takes over 1 year? Poor and slow support?
image de profil
@Multibagger I am very satisfied.
Better overview than with TR, fast support, savings plans (also by direct debit) free of charge, one-off purchases from €600 also free of charge.
Deposits / withdrawals sometimes take a day.
1
image de profil
@AlterMann One-off purchases from 501,- free of charge
image de profil
@Depot_7777 Oh, I made a typo. You're right.
image de profil
I'm at Scalable..... and have just checked them all, so a savings plan does not work for any of the items listed. How can I check whether fractions can be transferred?
1
image de profil
I'm with Finanzen.net Zero myself, I used it for cost reasons. If you don't have constant requests and have to communicate via tickets or email, it can take a few days. But if you only do your thing trading or running savings plans, I am satisfied. under 500,- per trade or derivative costs 1 euro, above that free of charge - really cheap, if you like, please use my referral link https://mein.finanzen-zero.net/depot-eroeffnen?aorefid=KWK-MMY6X74UQV70
Participez à la conversation