The reason for the current drop in stock prices is new plans by the U.S. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) regarding the Medicare Advantage program:
- Stricter audits: A new draft (“CRUSH rule”) allows billing errors identified in random samples to be extrapolated— retroactively to 2018.
- A risk running into the billions: According to estimates, this could result in the entire industry facing repayments of approximately $9 billion per year.
- Why it affects UNH: As the largest provider in this sector, such repayments would retroactively reduce profits already recognized in recent years.
Conclusion: It is still only a draft, on which insurers have until January 19, 2027 (lawsuits are likely to follow).
Is the market overreacting again here, or do you see a real risk?
