3Semana
10 overnight deposit accounts at ten different banks.
•
1515
•
3Semana
@Solitair Thanks, but that’s been thought through and deemed too risky.
1. Legally speaking, a money market account is a loan to the bank. If the bank goes bankrupt, your deposit is gone for the time being, and no one knows what happens next.
2. As far as I know, deposit insurance applies per person, not per account. At the very least, that’s unclear, and in a full-blown banking crisis, the system will simply switch to a per-person basis. Then everything over 100k is gone, just like in Cyprus a few years ago. And in our society, in the event of a crisis, no one gives a damn about people who’ve lost everything over 100k.
There needs to be more security here—significantly more security!
1. Legally speaking, a money market account is a loan to the bank. If the bank goes bankrupt, your deposit is gone for the time being, and no one knows what happens next.
2. As far as I know, deposit insurance applies per person, not per account. At the very least, that’s unclear, and in a full-blown banking crisis, the system will simply switch to a per-person basis. Then everything over 100k is gone, just like in Cyprus a few years ago. And in our society, in the event of a crisis, no one gives a damn about people who’ve lost everything over 100k.
There needs to be more security here—significantly more security!
•
33
•3Semana
@Epi Second: Deposit insurance applies per bank. That means if you have three accounts at the same bank, you’re only protected up to a total of €100,000; however, if you have accounts at three different banks, you’re protected up to three times that amount—€300,000.
I don’t see what’s controversial about that—it’s regulated by the Deposit Guarantee Act.
First: what happens then is second.
You could also spread your money across savings banks and cooperative banks; as far as I know, they have their own separate guarantee systems that provide additional protection.
I don’t think you’ll find “much more” security than that.
Maybe use some of it to buy canned food in case the Russians invade or something like that.
I don’t see what’s controversial about that—it’s regulated by the Deposit Guarantee Act.
First: what happens then is second.
You could also spread your money across savings banks and cooperative banks; as far as I know, they have their own separate guarantee systems that provide additional protection.
I don’t think you’ll find “much more” security than that.
Maybe use some of it to buy canned food in case the Russians invade or something like that.
•
22
•3Semana
@Solitair Let’s assume the law isn’t amended on an ad hoc basis—which I think is likely—and that the deposit insurance remains per bank, not per person.
How much money is actually in the deposit insurance fund? €6 billion? That would barely be enough to compensate maybe 1% of all Commerzbank customers. And then what? Then the chaos begins.
So: why do you think the deposit insurance is safer than a short-term German government bond? I think that in the event of a crisis, the bonds will be paid off first, and then any bank accounts will be compensated.
How much money is actually in the deposit insurance fund? €6 billion? That would barely be enough to compensate maybe 1% of all Commerzbank customers. And then what? Then the chaos begins.
So: why do you think the deposit insurance is safer than a short-term German government bond? I think that in the event of a crisis, the bonds will be paid off first, and then any bank accounts will be compensated.
•
11
•
3Semana
@Epi I consider this sequence to be speculative. In the event of a full-blown crisis, there will be a haircut, and it is unclear how it will be weighted.
•
33
•
@Epi I also think I read somewhere that, in case of doubt, the limit is 100k per person.
••
3Semana
But seriously. Do your parents expect society to completely collapse in the next 5–10 years? If so, I'm afraid even money invested safely won't do them any good.
•
11
•3Semana
@Wealth-Accelerator Kommer points out that it applies per person—or could apply, I think.
•
22
•3Semana
@Applesplit I don't think this is a matter of personal expectations. Rather, it's about weighing all the relevant factors as objectively as possible.
••
