Both ETFs perform identically. The advantages and disadvantages depend only on how you use them.
When you run such simulations, keep in mind that Getquin does not provide the exact price for past entry points, but only a random closing price from around that point in time. That might well be the sole reason for the slight difference.
When you run such simulations, keep in mind that Getquin does not provide the exact price for past entry points, but only a random closing price from around that point in time. That might well be the sole reason for the slight difference.
•
11
•
@DoppelSchlechtMinus i have tryed to pull the date 5yerara back and inseted the price manually from more reliable source and in fact the total rerun on 5 years time is practlally identical, so i was wrong
•
11
•@madtao still if I reinvest the dividend the total retun on distribuition will be higher
••
@madtao These are not even independent funds, but sub-funds based on the same portfolio.
The only way to outperform the acc version by manually reinvesting the yield from the dist version, is when the stock market just happens to go down in the couple of days between the extraction of the yield from the fund and your reinvestment transaction. Statistically, that happens less often than the opposite.
Then add spread, fees and taxes to your deficit, if applicable.
It is just completely unrealistic to beat the acc version by doing that. And that's coming from a happy owner of the dist version.
The only way to outperform the acc version by manually reinvesting the yield from the dist version, is when the stock market just happens to go down in the couple of days between the extraction of the yield from the fund and your reinvestment transaction. Statistically, that happens less often than the opposite.
Then add spread, fees and taxes to your deficit, if applicable.
It is just completely unrealistic to beat the acc version by doing that. And that's coming from a happy owner of the dist version.
•
11
•
@madtao you might want to update the original post
••
@DoppelSchlechtMinus To be more precise with the wording, these are different share classes of the same fund. For reference, you can see in this document https://fund-docs.vanguard.com/ie00bk5bqt80-en.pdf that "the fund" was issued in 2012 (VWRL) and the "share class" in 2019 (VWCE).
••