9Lun·

Following on from my post of just under a week ago:

I actually found a thread in the official TR forum where some people are also "complaining" that they are missing the dividend from August 20. But there are also some who are still missing the dividend from June 2024. And indeed: I am also missing the June 2024 dividend.

Some people in the forum have already contacted BaFin and/or a lawyer. But TR seems to be screwing up again.

Confirms me again to look around for another broker...

$PETR3 (+0,57 %)
$PETR4 (+0,97 %)

Ella Marie Waschbär

@DividendenWaschbaer

9Lun·

Petroleo Brasileiro dividend received?

Hello, I have a question for all those who hold Petroleo Brasileiro shares.

$PETR3 (+0,57 %)
$PETR4 (+0,97 %)

There was a payday on 20.08. I have the share at TR. So far, the dividend has sometimes arrived a week later. But never later. Now it's already been 3 weeks. I would be interested to know whether others have already received the dividend (regardless of which broker) on August 20?

The TR says that it may take some time. Just a prefabricated answer. I'm just surprised that, unlike usual, it's already been 3 weeks. It would be interesting to know whether this is a TR-specific problem or a general one.

Thank you very much.

34 Comentarios

S.A.U.@SAUgut77

9Lun

Just get rid of the filth....also the broker 😉

•

Ella Marie Waschbär@DividendenWaschbaer

9Lun

@SAUgut77 Yes, I've had enough of this. I'm really someone who knows that mistakes can happen. I'm really patient. But I've really had enough.

•

S.A.U.@SAUgut77

9Lun

@DividendenWaschbaer Mistakes in all honor, but that's already the program 🤫🫡

•

Ella Marie Waschbär@DividendenWaschbaer

9Lun

@SAUgut77 That's how I see it too

•

Anne@AnneS

9Lun

@SAUgut77 Which broker are you with?

••

S.A.U.@SAUgut77

9Lun

@AnneS smartbroker+...no "interest" on the cash, but satisfied so far.

•

Anne@AnneS

9Lun

@SAUgut77 just thinking about setting up an additional one at the ing 🤣

••

S.A.U.@SAUgut77

9Lun

@AnneS well, when it reaches a certain amount for me, I will also move from the discount store to the supermarket for the most part.

But I get my divis on time, good purchase conditions, could also trade on various other exchanges and don't need the support so far, so it's a good fit right now.

•

Anne@AnneS

9Lun

@SAUgut77 That's exactly my problem 😅 from a certain size, I feel the need for more security 😅 let's see 😄

•

S.A.U.@SAUgut77

9Lun

@AnneS there are enough alternatives to the discounter...which broker are you with?

••

Anne@AnneS

9Lun

@SAUgut77 Scalable and comdirect... I still have to open something for my friend... I'm thinking about using another neobroker or a direct bank

••

Ver una respuesta más

Ronald@AlterMann

9Lun

Should I give you another update on the securities account transfer I initiated at the end of JUNE?
It's still not done correctly because TR can't do it. And no, it's not anyone else's fault - only TR's.

•

Ella Marie Waschbär@DividendenWaschbaer

9Lun

@AlterMann I once reacted with sos, because the thumbs up seems inappropriate 😅

Yes, I'll be moving away from TR soon too. Then there will be regular transfers but only a few positions at a time. I'm not in a hurry from that point of view. Petroleo Brasileiro will definitely be the first stock to go. 😅

•

Dividende > Zinsen@GoDividend

9Lun

@DividendenWaschbaer already done😅
Everything is slumbering at the Ing and that's a good thing

•

Dividendensammler@DividendensammIer

9Lun

I'm also considering transferring TR completely to Scalable or Consors. I feel a bit more secure with a larger bank for 6-digit deposits and I also get dividends faster 😂

•

Ella Marie Waschbär@DividendenWaschbaer

9Lun

@DividendensammIer In principle, TR is super fast with dividends. Sometimes I even get them 1 or 2 days in advance and even on Saturdays.
But there are always outliers.

•

Leo@MCKrummel-Divi-Holding

9Lun

Why does Homer never have a problem with his 150 shares that almost all pay out! 😂

•

Ella Marie Waschbär@DividendenWaschbaer

9Lun

@MCKrummel-Divi-Holding I think that @Simpson simply doesn't realize when one of the 150 dividends a day is missing.

•

Homer@Simpson

9Lun

@DividendenWaschbaer Fortunately, there is getquin and you can see exactly what is coming soon 😂 otherwise I probably wouldn't notice if something was missing 😂 but all-clear all dividends come on time 😂 but I don't have any exotic stocks in my portfolio either 😂

•

All-in-or-nothing@All-in-or-nothing

9Lun

@Simpson I wouldn't necessarily describe Petrobras as exotic😅. And even with "more exotic" stocks, EVERYTHING should run smoothly with a sensible broker laufen🤷🏼‍♂️.

•

Sparfuchs@Reinecke

9Lun

Finanzen.net Zero , you can now even reinvest the dividend directly.

•

Ella Marie Waschbär@DividendenWaschbaer

9Lun

@Reinecke Yes, I'm already there. But Baader Bank isn't that great either 😅
Especially as I have to report every transaction to my employer and Baader Bank charges €2.50 per report.

It will probably be DKB. An alternative from the neobrokers.

••

Sparfuchs@Reinecke

9Lun

@DividendenWaschbaer yes with the French. withholding tax. But a trading fee of 10 euros or more for both buying and selling is of course quite an announcement. The support for Gazprom shares is not exactly competent either. However, the app is far above Zero and TR.

••

Ella Marie Waschbär@DividendenWaschbaer

9Lun

@Reinecke Purchases continue at TR. Apart from maybe the Swiss or something.
But then I transfer the shares semi-annually or annually. TR is simply (still/again) too uncertain for me.

•

Dani@Danibanani

9Lun

@DividendenWaschbaer The APP doesn't show me the June dividend either, but you can see it in more detail under Account statement. Please check this for yourself, because in my case it matches the cash position and the added June dividend.

PS: It was paid out to me on June 29!

•

Ella Marie Waschbär@DividendenWaschbaer

9Lun

@Danibanani Absolutely correct. And I even saw that I already had the statement before. Because it is recorded in Portfolio Performance. I must have reacted a bit hastily.

Nonetheless, it is of course unacceptable that the statement is missing. Good thing I downloaded it back then. Must have happened in the course of the account changeover or the dividend problem in the summer.

Nevertheless, the dividend from August is still missing, and the next one is due tomorrow. I'm a bit more reassured now, but I'm still going to look elsewhere. Unfortunately, things are piling up at TR.

Thank you very much for your help!

••

Dani@Danibanani

9Lun

@DividendenWaschbaer Always a pleasure! ✌️Ja I am also considering setting sail for TR. I will probably switch to ING, but I will wait a little longer. There are still too many people who have problems with the securities account transfer.

•

Tom1966@Tom1966

9Lun

I have the same problem with TR. Last Charles Schwab is also missing...

•

Markus@financial_genius_20

9Lun

Just get away from there and if I may give you a tip: look for a full-service bank broker that manages everything itself and does not outsource the core job to anyone (Baader, Clearstream,...) that is as cheap as possible and keeps the QualityOfService correspondingly low. The extra few euros are well worth the reliability and nerves saved.

••

Ella Marie Waschbär@DividendenWaschbaer

9Lun

@financial_genius_20 I absolutely agree.
I will go to S Broker or DKB. ING is not responding to my request and therefore apparently has no interest in me.
The shares will then be transferred to this broker. I will continue to buy on TR. That way they get something from the fees and S Broker or DKB also earn money from me through the currency conversions 🤷🏻‍♂️😂

••

Sascha Lamber@ScreamFD

9Lun

@DividendenWaschbaer S Broker is the Sparkasse, isn't it relatively expensive? I find Comdirect relatively good, with a regular savings plan free of charge and many stock exchanges available, I especially like the IPO subscription option.

••

Ronald@AlterMann

9Lun

@ScreamFD IPO with comdirect is great. But the number of savings plans there is very limited

••

Ella Marie Waschbär@DividendenWaschbaer

9Lun

@ScreamFD That's right, S Broker belongs to Sparkasse. They are cheaper than DKB, depending on use (it depends on the services you need and the transaction volume).
But they have the Sparkasse in the background (so they are accessible), offer free currency accounts (interesting for later), offer help with withholding tax refunds and advance exemption for all countries.

I probably won't trade there anyway, unless I want to buy something for myself in larger amounts (which are still small) directly abroad (Tokyo, NY).

The decision is not yet final.
I've already read a lot of positive but also a lot of negative things about Comdirect. Just Commerzbank. I am rather undecided.

••